Understanding Real Estate Market Cycles and How To Invest Based On Your Own Research
A lot of people have been asking me how I do my research for places to invest in. Here’s my attempt to explain the process.
It started when I sold my home and was wondering where to invest the proceeds. I moved into a condo that had previously been a rental so I didn’t need any of the money to buy a primary residence. I thought that California was overpriced and I definitely wanted to invest out of state.
I spent a lot of time and money reading books and proprietary reports about market cycles, its causes and effects. One great book is Bruce Norris’s California Countdown. I found out the periodically the California market experiences a rapid run-up in pricing, then it crashes, stagnates, and then rises again. As housing becomes less and less affordable, people start to migrate to neighboring states.
How do you know people are starting to migrate out of your city witout waiting for the 2008 census? You can see these trends through the Unofficial Migration Indicator at www.uhaul.com. Check out the cost of a one-way rental for any given city and any other city. Let’s consider the cost of renting a small truck between San Diego, CA and Phoenix, AZ. It cost $225 to rent to from San Diego to Phoenix but only $101 to bring it back! This means that there are probably twice as many people moving out of San Diego and into Phoenix than the other way around. This is basic supply and demand. So you want to make sure that the price is constant both ways or in your favor.
You can also check out population and job growth trends at a variety of different websites, but don’t always assume the given data is correct. You can get data at cities chambers of commerce sites or by google searches.
here are some useful links:
city-data.com
US Census Bureau
Milken Institute
I also found out that whenever prices in neighboring states start to rise, California property prices have started to peak . This is because at the top of the cycle Californians can’t afford to live here anymore and they start moving out of California and into places where housing is more affordable. Eventually as these places begin to rise and CA prices begin to drop, the lure of California becomes irrestible and the cycle starts all over again. Accordingly, there are states that
1) follow an opposite cycle from Calfornia [contrarian states]
2) follow a similar cycle to California
3) states that do nothing or do their own thing.
Contrarian states are states like Arizona, Oregon, Utah, Colorado,etc
Similar states are Connecticut, Florida, Maryland, Nevada, New Hampshire, etc
Limited movement states are Alaska, Arkansas, Idaho,Indiana, the Carolinas and Dakotas, Ohio,etc.
Each state behaves differently so don’t take this as gospel. Do your due diligence.
Look at prospective states or cities and find out how they’ve done historically. I looked at several states before I settled on Utah.
AZ – already too much appreciation in the residential market. I had missed the boat. vacancies are sky-high. commercial still seems good.
TX – It really hasn’t done anything exciting in the past 25 yrs. its a safe place to park money. plus the 3% property tax kills your cashflow.
NM – its looks like a safe place to park your money. a few people I know used to live there and said the local government was not pro-biz.
FL – too late to the party. plus 2% property tax. i had bought 2 pre-construction houses there in early 2004, but the builder had gone under, so I basically lost out on several months of appreciation.
WA – mainly looked at seattle since i went there in july 2004. local economy not
diverse enough for my liking. only 2 main biz – starbucks and microsoft. although the projected job growth is there, the salaries still seem low compared to the house prices/rents.
NY – looked at upstate new york. property tax is over 5%. job growth and population growth are both negative. good cashflow but i’ll wait for the indicators to turn before venturing into this territory.
UT – finally something i like! Positive job and population growth. The market was been flat for several years and had just started to perk up. saw 6.5% avg appreciation state-wide last year – that made front page news!!! govenor is pro-biz (he would be, he’s the son of a billionaire!). SLC is land locked. There’s limited land, always a good sign. Saint George is a hot market too. Also, Utah follows an opposite cycle from california. During the last cycle between 1993 and 1997, Utah saw a 64% appreciation, while California saw only 3%. Between 1999 and 2004, while Southern California saw a 125% gain, Utah saw less than 5%.
In 2003 Utah was 49th in the country in terms of appreciation, beating only Texas. However in 2004, it jumped to the 36th spot. Between 2001 and 2003, Utah saw 21 months of zero or negative job growth, which is why prices didn’t boom in a low interest rate period. 6 months ago, it was 2nd in the nation in terms of job growth (3.7%) lagging only behind Nevada. Since the beginning of 2005, the unemployment rate has been lower than the national average.
Utah also has the nation’s highest birth rates and life expectancy. Over the next 25 years, its estimated that the population will grow between 58 and 75% making it the 5th fastest growing state.
At this point I stopped looking for places to invest and started looking for deals and a team. [feel free to email me for contacts and I'll hook you up with them]. I also tied up with local builders and developers. I booked several pre-construction homes there and have already closed on 5 of them. I just bought another lot there next to Lake Utah with a build-out time of 12 months. Some of them have gone up 10-20% since the time i’ve booked them.
It definitely pays to do your own research!
If you found this post helpful, consider donating to my coffee fund!![[del.icio.us]](http://images.del.icio.us/static/img/delicious.small.gif){kind=small}
- Living off dividends [or how to invest in Real Estate for cashflow] While surfing onlne, I came across this blog post: Real Estate as an asset class. Basically this guy wants to be able to live off his dividends at some point and his blog is devoted to that. He's wondering how real estate fits in. He invests in REITS but isn't......
- Mortgage Meltdown: The Worst Is Yet To Come! Check out this 12 minute video from 60 Minutes. There's another wave of mortgage defaults on the way, this time from Alt-A & Option-Arm (also called Negative-Amortization or Neg-Am) loans. As opposed to the subprime loans which were worth almost $1 Trillion, these two groups make up nearly $1.5 Trillion. ......
- Housing Continues To Get Worse Housing continues to get worse. According to a recent article in BusinessWeek: A strong job market, the thriving casino and convention industry, and the highest population growth in the country made Vegas a boomtown for builders. Sin City represented one of the top five markets.Today, new homes are empty and......
Related Websites
- No Doubt About It: A Double Dip in Housing is Certain When one of the few banking analysts who correctly predicted the financial crisis (aka debt crisis) and the subsequent popping of the real estate bubble takes the time to speak, you should make the time investment to listen. Based upon weak economic fundamentals across the board, Meredith Whitney is still......
- Creative Ways of Investing in the Real Estate Market You can become a successful real estate investor despite the recent state of the economy. The trick lies in devising creative and non-traditional strategies for your real estate deals and making them work. Devising new techniques does not necessarily mean creating ideas or methods that have never been used before.......
- Figuring Out When to Start a Diet The process of starting a diet is probably one of the most difficult steps you can take when you’re getting started on the road to fitness. It’s not easy to commit to making changes in your life, especially if they are big changes, and it is all too easy to......
[All content is copyright of Living Off Dividends & Passive Income]
March 19th, 2006 at 3:16 pm
Hi,
Am I too late for the party at Utah, or is there still possiblities. Just caught a newsbyte about some place in Utah (close to Las Vegas though) having one of the highest real estate appreciation. Any pointers would be appreciated
March 20th, 2006 at 2:24 pm
i think there’s still time to get in. i expect a sharp run up in prices this summer.
April 3rd, 2006 at 4:43 pm
great article. I like you thinking. I am selling my fifth property here in CA. I sold three in Anaheim and 2 in Inland Empire ( 1 SB and 1 Riverside). Pls send me more info about your contacts in Utah. Definitely looks better than the stock market where I plan to put some of money at least for now.
shayig@yahoo.com
Mike
April 8th, 2006 at 3:15 am
I love the blog..It contains alot of good information.
Hope i am not late for the party, please feel free to send me the juicy details on anything at hoctro_mii@yahoo.com
Till then I cant wait to read more blogs from you. THANKS!
April 24th, 2006 at 7:14 pm
This is a great site! Please send me your contacts! tony@alrconsultants.com. I have been involved in creating a preconstruction opportunity in florida and now I am duplicating it in georgia.
August 16th, 2006 at 7:58 pm
Hi there. I am a real estate investor up here in Canada and thought I would share some information on the BOOMING Real Estate market in Alberta, Canada. Let me tell you, we are sitting on an absolute Gold Mine…some calling it the Real Estate opportunity of a lifetime.
For example, property values in Calgary, AB increased 54% in the last 12 months. We bought a house for $350K 2 years ago and it was just appraised for $545K…an increase of $195K in two years!!!
Edmonton, AB increased 28% in the last 8 months. A recent real estate article stated values are increasing at a rate of $160 per day!
Heard of the Athabasca Oil Sands in Fort Mcmurray, AB…people are literally renting garages to live in for upwards of $1000 per month because there is no where to live. 2 bedroom condos rent out for $1500-2000 per month and are still relatively afforable selling in the $160-220K range.
If you are interested in more information on Real Estate opportunities in Alberta, Canada…drop me an email at mdobson@sasktel.net